The Significance of Oranges in Jeanette's Life
In the novel, oranges symbolize the simplicity and constraints of Jeanette's childhood. The motif of oranges is introduced when Jeanette, at seven years old, becomes temporarily deaf—a condition her mother refuses to acknowledge as a medical issue, preferring to view it as a spiritual test. It is only after intervention by a church member that Jeanette receives medical treatment. During her hospital stay, her mother's visits are marked by the gift of oranges, which Jeanette associates with her mother's love and the limited perspective she is offered. The fruit becomes emblematic of the narrow life her mother envisions for her.Exploring Sexuality and Relationships
Jeanette's understanding of sexuality and relationships is initially shaped by her mother's strict religious beliefs, which portray such matters in a negative light. However, as a teenager, Jeanette develops a romantic relationship with Melanie, a girl she meets at a market. This relationship defies the church's teachings against homosexuality and sets Jeanette on a path of self-discovery. The discovery of their relationship by the church community leads to Melanie's repentance and departure. Jeanette's subsequent relationship with Katy, another member of the church, further challenges the community's conservative views on sexuality.Confrontation with the Church and Exorcism
The church's reaction to Jeanette's relationship with Melanie is severe, culminating in an attempt to perform an exorcism on her. Jeanette is locked in a room for over a day, deprived of food and water, in an effort to purge her of her 'sin'. During this ordeal, she experiences visions, including one of an orange demon, which symbolizes the pervasive influence of the church in her life. Jeanette pretends to repent to end the exorcism, all the while internally struggling to reconcile her feelings for Melanie with her faith.Jeanette's Evolving Role in the Church and Departure
After the exorcism, Jeanette becomes more involved in the church, but her continued relationships with women lead to a prohibition on women preaching. This, along with the church's view that her leadership roles have caused her to "act like a man," prompts Jeanette to leave the church and her home. She takes on various jobs, including driving an ice cream truck and working at a funeral parlour. A significant moment occurs when Jeanette is excluded from the funeral of Elsie Norris, a church elder, but manages to attend incognito, only to be publicly disowned by her mother afterward.Jeanette's Return Home and Reflection on Identity
Despite the estrangement, Jeanette returns home for Christmas, seeking a sense of belonging. She discovers that her mother's church has disbanded due to internal corruption, and her mother is struggling to maintain a sense of community through a new radio ministry. Jeanette's visit highlights the collapse of the once-defining church and her mother's unwavering commitment to their faith. The narrative concludes with Jeanette's recognition that her identity is not confined by the church's doctrines, and she is free to create her own path while still valuing parts of her past.Themes and Analysis of the Novel
"Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit" examines themes such as religion, gender roles, community, and sexuality. The novel critiques the oppressive use of religion as a tool for control and the restrictive gender roles that limit personal expression. Jeanette's story illustrates the complexities of identity and the challenges of finding one's place in a world that often demands conformity. The title of the novel serves as a metaphor for the variety of life's options, suggesting that there is more to life than what is initially presented to us. Winterson's narrative portrays the difficult yet rewarding journey of self-discovery and the bravery required to live authentically.
