The New Right and the Nuclear Family
Concept Map
The New Right movement, influential in the 1980s, champions traditional nuclear family values as crucial for societal stability. It criticizes family diversity and welfare policies, linking them to social issues like crime and poverty. The movement supports policies to strengthen the nuclear family and reduce welfare dependency, with empirical backing from researchers like Norman Dennis and George Erdos. Charles Murray's concept of the 'underclass' also aligns with New Right ideology.
Summary
Outline
The New Right's Perspective on Family and Society
The New Right is a conservative political movement that gained prominence in the 1980s, particularly influencing the policies of the UK government during the tenures of Prime Ministers Margaret Thatcher and John Major. This movement emphasizes traditional values in both economic and social spheres, advocating for limited government intervention in markets and the reinforcement of traditional family structures. Although the New Right is not a structural theory like functionalism or Marxism, it shares with functionalism the belief in a society that functions harmoniously when traditional roles and institutions are preserved. The New Right holds that the nuclear family, with distinct roles for men and women, is the optimal setting for child-rearing and societal stability.The New Right's Ideal of the Nuclear Family
The New Right idealizes the nuclear family, which it defines as a self-sufficient unit composed of a married couple, with a male breadwinner and a female homemaker. This family structure is posited as the most effective for nurturing and socializing children, providing them with a stable environment and clear role models. The New Right argues that societal problems such as crime, poverty, and moral decline are consequences of the erosion of the nuclear family, evidenced by increasing divorce rates, the prevalence of single-parent households, and the rise of cohabitation. To address these issues, the New Right advocates for a revival of traditional family values.Critique of Family Diversity and Welfare State Policies
The New Right perspective is critical of the diversification of family structures, including single-parent families, reconstituted families, cohabiting couples, and families headed by same-sex couples. It contends that state policies providing support to these non-traditional family forms, through welfare benefits and legal recognition, foster a dependency culture. The New Right argues that such policies encourage irresponsible behaviors, such as having children outside of marriage and avoiding work, leading to a reliance on state assistance rather than self-sufficiency.The Impact of Divorce and Non-Traditional Family Forms
New Right theorists argue that the ease of obtaining a divorce has contributed to the breakdown of marriages and the rise of single-parent and reconstituted families. They claim that these family forms have detrimental effects on children, including increased risks of poverty, educational underachievement, and criminal behavior. Furthermore, they assert that policies that support non-traditional family structures weaken the societal role and value of the nuclear family, leading to its diminished prevalence and influence.Advocating for Social Policies to Strengthen the Nuclear Family
In an effort to reinforce the nuclear family, the New Right supports policies that reduce welfare dependency and make divorce more challenging. They propose that cutting welfare benefits for single-parent families and the unemployed would incentivize work and reduce instances of teenage pregnancy. They also believe that making divorce more difficult would encourage couples to remain together, thereby preserving the nuclear family model.Empirical Support for the New Right's Family Views
Research conducted by Norman Dennis and George Erdos, as well as various statistical data, support the New Right's views on the family. Studies have shown that children from single-parent families, especially boys lacking a father figure, face more significant challenges in terms of health, education, and behavior. Figures from the Work and Pensions Secretary Iain Duncan Smith and The Marriage Foundation have highlighted the higher rates of poverty and instability in single-parent families, bolstering the New Right's argument for the societal benefits of the nuclear family.Charles Murray's Concept of the Underclass
Charles Murray, a key figure in New Right thought, posits that the disintegration of the nuclear family contributes to the creation of an 'underclass' characterized by single parenthood, teenage pregnancies, and a cycle of welfare dependency. He advocates for reduced state intervention as a means to foster individual responsibility and prevent the perpetuation of this underclass across generations.Critiques of the New Right's Family Perspective
The New Right's perspective on the family has been met with criticism for its lack of tolerance for family diversity and its seemingly antiquated views on gender roles. Critics such as Robert Chester and feminist scholars argue that the nuclear family is not the sole effective family structure and that the New Right's stance often ignores the potential oppression of women within traditional family settings. Marxist theorists challenge the New Right by suggesting that it overlooks the role of the nuclear family in sustaining capitalist systems. Additionally, some critics argue that the media has exaggerated social problems to justify welfare reductions. The New Right's focus on single mothers is also criticized for neglecting the responsibilities of absent fathers.
Show More
Definition and Influence of the New Right
Conservative Political Movement
The New Right is a conservative political movement that gained prominence in the 1980s
Emphasis on Traditional Values
Limited Government Intervention
The New Right advocates for limited government intervention in markets and traditional family structures
Reinforcement of Traditional Family Structures
The New Right believes in the nuclear family as the optimal setting for child-rearing and societal stability
Comparison to Structural Theories
The New Right shares with functionalism the belief in a harmonious society when traditional roles and institutions are preserved
Idealization of the Nuclear Family
Definition of the Nuclear Family
The New Right defines the nuclear family as a self-sufficient unit composed of a married couple with distinct gender roles
Effectiveness for Nurturing and Socializing Children
The New Right argues that the nuclear family provides a stable environment and clear role models for children
Consequences of Erosion of the Nuclear Family
The New Right believes that societal problems such as crime and poverty are caused by the breakdown of the nuclear family
Criticism of Non-Traditional Family Structures
Disapproval of Diversification of Family Structures
The New Right is critical of single-parent families, reconstituted families, cohabiting couples, and same-sex couples
Belief in Negative Effects of Non-Traditional Families
The New Right argues that non-traditional family structures lead to societal problems and weaken the nuclear family's role and value
Opposition to State Policies Supporting Non-Traditional Families
The New Right believes that state policies providing support to non-traditional families foster a dependency culture and irresponsible behaviors
Proposed Solutions to Reinforce the Nuclear Family
Reduction of Welfare Dependency
The New Right proposes cutting welfare benefits for single-parent families and the unemployed to incentivize work and reduce teenage pregnancy
Difficulty of Obtaining Divorce
The New Right advocates for making divorce more challenging to encourage couples to remain together and preserve the nuclear family
Research Supporting the New Right's Views
Studies have shown the negative effects of non-traditional families on children, supporting the New Right's argument for the societal benefits of the nuclear family
The New Right and the Nuclear Family
Learn with Algor Education flashcards
Click on each card to learn more about the topic
00
New Right's influence on 1980s UK politics
Dominated by Thatcher and Major, stressed free markets, reduced state intervention.
01
New Right vs. Structural Theories
Unlike functionalism/Marxism, not a structural theory but shares functionalism's view on societal harmony.
02
New Right's stance on economic policy
Advocates for free-market capitalism, deregulation, and privatization of state-owned enterprises.
