The Spoils System in American Political History
Concept Map
Algorino
Edit available
The spoils system in American political history refers to the practice of rewarding supporters with public office positions. Originating before Andrew Jackson's era, it became prominent during his presidency. The Pendleton Civil Service Reform Act of 1883 initiated a shift towards merit-based federal employment, reducing patronage and leading to a professional civil service. This act also impacted political campaign financing and the nonpartisan nature of civil service, although the spoils system persisted at state and local levels into the mid-20th century.
Summary
Outline
The Spoils System in American Political History
The spoils system is a political practice where a victorious party gives public office positions to its supporters, friends, and relatives as a reward for their support, rather than hiring staff based on merit. This approach contrasts with the merit system, which emphasizes qualifications and performance. The spoils system became widespread in the United States and is often associated with President Andrew Jackson's administration after his 1828 election victory, drawing from the phrase "to the victor belong the spoils." However, the Pendleton Civil Service Reform Act of 1883 marked the beginning of a significant shift towards merit-based federal employment.The Origins and Evolution of the Spoils System
The spoils system was not initiated by Andrew Jackson, but has roots in the early political practices of the United States. Patronage was common during the administrations of early presidents, including George Washington, who appointed individuals aligned with the Federalist Party. John Adams and Thomas Jefferson also engaged in similar practices. The system gained prominence during the 1828 election, which saw the reemergence of a strong two-party system and the start of the Jacksonian era. Jackson's administration was notable for the extensive replacement of federal employees with his own supporters, which was seen as a defining moment for the spoils system.Civil Service Reform and the Pendleton Civil Service Act
The assassination of President James A. Garfield by a disgruntled office seeker in 1881 highlighted the dangers of the spoils system and catalyzed the movement for civil service reform. The Pendleton Civil Service Reform Act of 1883 established a bipartisan Civil Service Commission and mandated that federal jobs be awarded based on merit. Although the Act initially applied to a small fraction of government positions, it laid the groundwork for the expansion of the merit system, allowing presidents to classify more jobs as civil service positions. By the turn of the century, the majority of federal positions were filled through competitive exams, significantly diminishing the spoils system's role in federal employment.The Lasting Effects of the Pendleton Act on American Governance
The Pendleton Act's influence extended beyond curtailing patronage appointments. It was a cornerstone in the creation of a professional civil service and the evolution of the modern bureaucratic state in America. The Act also altered the landscape of political campaign financing, as parties could no longer depend on patronage positions for campaign contributions, leading them to seek funds from private donors. The Hatch Act of 1939 further separated politics from civil service by prohibiting federal employees from engaging in certain political activities, reinforcing the nonpartisan nature of the civil service.The Spoils System's Persistence in State and Local Governments
While the federal government moved towards a merit-based system, the spoils system persisted at the state and local levels for many years. Political machines like Tammany Hall in New York City wielded patronage power until the mid-20th century, and Chicago's city government operated under a patronage system until the Shakman Decrees of the 1970s and 1980s. Some states, such as Illinois, began to reform their bureaucracies earlier, but the transition away from the spoils system varied across the country, with some areas maintaining these practices longer than others.
Show More
Origins and Evolution of the Spoils System
Patronage in Early Political Practices
Early presidents, such as George Washington, John Adams, and Thomas Jefferson, engaged in patronage by appointing individuals aligned with their political party
Emergence of the Spoils System in the Jacksonian Era
Andrew Jackson's Administration
President Andrew Jackson's extensive replacement of federal employees with his own supporters marked a defining moment for the spoils system
Catalyst for Civil Service Reform
The assassination of President James A. Garfield in 1881 led to the movement for civil service reform and the passage of the Pendleton Civil Service Reform Act in 1883
Civil Service Reform and the Pendleton Civil Service Act
Establishment of the Civil Service Commission
The Pendleton Civil Service Reform Act of 1883 created a bipartisan Civil Service Commission to oversee the merit-based hiring of federal employees
Merit-Based Hiring
The Pendleton Act mandated that federal jobs be awarded based on qualifications and performance, rather than political affiliation
Expansion of the Merit System
The Pendleton Act paved the way for the expansion of the merit system, leading to the majority of federal positions being filled through competitive exams
Lasting Effects of the Pendleton Act on American Governance
Creation of a Professional Civil Service
The Pendleton Act played a significant role in the development of a professional civil service and the modern bureaucratic state in America
Impact on Political Campaign Financing
The Pendleton Act changed the landscape of political campaign financing by prohibiting parties from relying on patronage positions for contributions
Reinforcement of Nonpartisan Civil Service
The Hatch Act of 1939 further separated politics from civil service by prohibiting federal employees from engaging in certain political activities
Persistence of the Spoils System in State and Local Governments
Political Machines and Patronage Power
Some state and local governments, such as Tammany Hall in New York City and Chicago's city government, continued to operate under the spoils system until the mid-20th century
State Reforms and Transition Away from the Spoils System
While some states, like Illinois, began to reform their bureaucracies earlier, the transition away from the spoils system varied across the country
The Spoils System in American Political History
Learn with Algor Education flashcards
Click on each card to learn more about the topic
00
Origin of 'spoils system' phrase
Phrase 'to the victor belong the spoils' reflects the spoils system's practice of rewarding supporters with public office.
01
President associated with spoils system
President Andrew Jackson, post-1828 election, widely linked to the spoils system's implementation in the U.S.
02
Act initiating merit-based federal employment
Pendleton Civil Service Reform Act of 1883 began the transition to hiring federal employees based on merit.
