Parliamentary Sovereignty in the UK
Concept Map
Exploring the principle of parliamentary sovereignty in the UK, this overview examines its origins, development, and the balance of power between Parliament, the judiciary, and the monarchy. It also discusses the impact of devolution and the EU on UK sovereignty, highlighting the dynamic nature of this constitutional cornerstone.
Summary
Outline
The Principle of Parliamentary Sovereignty in the UK
Parliamentary sovereignty is the central tenet of the United Kingdom's constitution, which posits that the UK Parliament is the supreme legal authority capable of enacting, amending, or repealing any law. This principle has evolved through historical events and is not formally codified but rather arises from important legal and constitutional conventions. It implies that no Parliament can create laws that future Parliaments cannot change, and no body, including the courts, can question the validity of Parliament's enacted laws. This doctrine reflects the unique nature of the UK's constitution, which is a blend of statutes, case law, historical documents, and unwritten conventions.The Evolution of the UK Parliament's Authority
The authority of the UK Parliament has developed from early advisory councils to the monarch into a sovereign legislative body. The Magna Carta of 1215 was an early influence on the development of parliamentary power, establishing the principle that the king could not levy taxes without the consent of his royal council. The English Civil War and the Glorious Revolution of 1688 were pivotal events that further shifted the balance of power from the monarchy to Parliament. The Bill of Rights 1689 and the Act of Settlement 1701 established Parliament's authority over the monarchy, including the right to determine the line of succession and to legislate without the king's interference.Royal Assent and the Monarch's Role in Legislation
Royal assent is the final step for a bill to become law in the UK, signifying the monarch's formal approval. While the monarch retains the theoretical power to refuse royal assent, in practice, it has become a formality, and assent has not been refused since the early 18th century. The role of the monarch in the legislative process is now largely ceremonial, reflecting the constitutional principle that the sovereign acts on the advice of the elected government. The last time royal assent was refused was by Queen Anne in 1708, and since then, it has been granted as a matter of course.The War Damage Act 1965: An Illustration of Parliamentary Sovereignty
The War Damage Act 1965 exemplifies the principle of parliamentary sovereignty. The Act was passed in response to a House of Lords' decision that the government should compensate the Burmah Oil Company for the destruction of its oil installations during World War II, which were demolished to impede the Japanese advance. By enacting the War Damage Act, Parliament effectively reversed the House of Lords' judgment, demonstrating its power to make and unmake any law, including changing the law retrospectively to affect rights and obligations.Limitations and Checks on Parliamentary Sovereignty
Although Parliament is sovereign, the UK's political system includes several checks and balances that influence legislative power. The separation of powers is not absolute, as the executive is drawn from the legislature and the judiciary has limited power to challenge parliamentary legislation. However, the judiciary can review executive actions and, through the Human Rights Act 1998, can declare parliamentary acts incompatible with the European Convention on Human Rights, prompting Parliament to reconsider the legislation. Additionally, the principle of parliamentary sovereignty is politically constrained by the electorate, as governments must maintain the confidence of the House of Commons to stay in power.Devolution and the European Union's Influence on UK Sovereignty
Devolution has introduced a new dimension to parliamentary sovereignty, with Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland now possessing their own legislatures for certain domestic issues, although the UK Parliament retains the power to legislate on any matter. The UK's membership in the European Union introduced a layer of supranational law, which had primacy over national law. However, following the Brexit referendum and the subsequent European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018, the UK has reclaimed legislative autonomy, and EU law is no longer supreme over UK legislation.Conclusion: The Nature of UK Parliamentary Sovereignty
In summary, the UK Parliament's sovereignty is a complex and dynamic principle that underpins the British constitutional framework. While it appears absolute, it operates within a system shaped by historical developments, political practices, and legal interpretations. The UK's uncodified constitution allows for a flexible approach to governance, with Parliament at its core as the ultimate legal authority. However, this power is balanced by political realities, devolution, and international obligations, ensuring that the principle of parliamentary sovereignty adapts to changing circumstances.
Show More
Definition and Evolution of Parliamentary Sovereignty
Central Tenet of UK's Constitution
Parliamentary sovereignty is the principle that the UK Parliament is the supreme legal authority capable of enacting, amending, or repealing any law
Historical Influences on Parliamentary Power
Magna Carta of 1215
The Magna Carta established the principle that the king could not levy taxes without the consent of his royal council, influencing the development of parliamentary power
English Civil War and Glorious Revolution
The English Civil War and Glorious Revolution shifted the balance of power from the monarchy to Parliament, solidifying its authority over the monarchy
Role of Royal Assent
Royal assent is the final step for a bill to become law in the UK, signifying the monarch's formal approval, although it is now largely ceremonial
Limitations and Checks on Parliamentary Sovereignty
Separation of Powers
The separation of powers in the UK's political system is not absolute, as the executive is drawn from the legislature and the judiciary has limited power to challenge parliamentary legislation
Judicial Review and Human Rights Act
The judiciary can review executive actions and declare parliamentary acts incompatible with the European Convention on Human Rights, prompting Parliament to reconsider the legislation
Political Constraints
The principle of parliamentary sovereignty is politically constrained by the electorate, as governments must maintain the confidence of the House of Commons to stay in power
Devolution and International Obligations
Devolution in the UK
Devolution has introduced a new dimension to parliamentary sovereignty, with Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland now possessing their own legislatures for certain domestic issues
Supranational Law and EU Membership
The UK's membership in the European Union introduced a layer of supranational law, which had primacy over national law
Brexit and Reclaimed Legislative Autonomy
Following the Brexit referendum and the subsequent European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018, the UK has reclaimed legislative autonomy, and EU law is no longer supreme over UK legislation
Parliamentary Sovereignty in the UK
Learn with Algor Education flashcards
Click on each card to learn more about the topic
00
Legal authority of UK Parliament
UK Parliament can enact, amend, or repeal any law, supreme over all other bodies.
01
Codification of UK's parliamentary sovereignty
Not formally codified; based on conventions and historical legal events.
02
Limitation on Parliament's legislative power
No law can be passed that future Parliaments cannot change, ensuring legislative flexibility.
