The New Jersey Plan and the Virginia Plan: A Debate on State Representation at the Constitutional Convention of 1787
Concept Map
The New Jersey Plan, proposed by William Paterson in 1787, sought to maintain equal representation for states in a unicameral legislature. It contrasted with the Virginia Plan's proportional representation and influenced the Great Compromise, leading to the current bicameral Congress with a Senate that upholds the principle of state equality. The plan's emphasis on smaller states' interests played a pivotal role in the U.S. federal system's development, ensuring a balanced legislative process.
Summary
Outline
The New Jersey Plan: A Vision for Equal State Representation
The New Jersey Plan, presented by William Paterson at the Constitutional Convention of 1787, offered a vision for the United States government that would preserve the influence of smaller states. In contrast to the Virginia Plan's preference for proportional representation, the New Jersey Plan proposed a unicameral legislature with equal representation for each state, akin to the existing system under the Articles of Confederation. It aimed to enhance the powers of the federal government to levy taxes and regulate commerce while maintaining the principle of state equality in the legislature.The Virginia Plan: A Call for Proportional Representation
The Virginia Plan, drafted by James Madison, advocated for a new federal government structure with a bicameral legislature based on state population or wealth. This proposal was designed to give larger states more influence in the national government, which smaller states vehemently opposed. The debate over representation was a central issue at the Convention, with smaller states fearing the loss of their equal status and larger states seeking to ensure their interests were adequately represented due to their greater populations.The Structure and Proposals of the New Jersey Plan
The New Jersey Plan's structure included a single-chamber Congress where each state would have one vote, reflecting the principle of state sovereignty. The plan proposed giving Congress the power to tax, regulate interstate and international commerce, and enforce these powers. It also called for the creation of a plural executive, appointed by Congress, who could be removed at the request of a majority of state governors. Furthermore, the plan suggested a federal judiciary with a Supreme Tribunal, which would serve as the highest judicial authority in the nation.The Rejection of the New Jersey Plan and the Great Compromise
The New Jersey Plan was ultimately rejected by the Constitutional Convention, with a majority favoring the Virginia Plan's approach to representation. However, the intense debate between large and small states led to the Great Compromise, or the Connecticut Compromise, which proposed a bicameral legislature with proportional representation in the House of Representatives and equal representation in the Senate. This compromise was instrumental in moving the Convention forward and laid the groundwork for the structure of the U.S. Congress.The Enduring Influence of the New Jersey Plan
Although the New Jersey Plan was not adopted in its original form, its legacy endures in the structure of the U.S. Senate, where each state is represented equally. The plan's insistence on protecting the interests of smaller states was a critical factor in the development of the federal system, ensuring that all states, regardless of size, would have a voice in the legislative process. The New Jersey Plan's contributions to the debate on state sovereignty and representation continue to be reflected in the balance of power between the states and the federal government.
Show More
The New Jersey Plan
Structure
The New Jersey Plan proposed a unicameral legislature with equal representation for each state, a plural executive appointed by Congress, and a federal judiciary with a Supreme Tribunal
Proposals
Powers of Congress
The New Jersey Plan aimed to enhance the powers of the federal government to levy taxes, regulate commerce, and enforce these powers
Plural Executive
The New Jersey Plan suggested a plural executive, appointed by Congress and removable at the request of a majority of state governors
Federal Judiciary
The New Jersey Plan proposed a federal judiciary with a Supreme Tribunal as the highest judicial authority in the nation
Enduring Influence
The New Jersey Plan's legacy endures in the structure of the U.S. Senate, where each state is represented equally, and its contributions to the debate on state sovereignty and representation continue to be reflected in the balance of power between the states and the federal government
The Virginia Plan
Structure
The Virginia Plan proposed a bicameral legislature based on state population or wealth
Proposals
Powers of Congress
The Virginia Plan aimed to give larger states more influence in the national government by granting Congress the power to tax, regulate commerce, and enforce these powers
Bicameral Legislature
The Virginia Plan proposed a bicameral legislature with proportional representation in the House of Representatives and equal representation in the Senate
Rejection and Compromise
The Virginia Plan was ultimately rejected, but its ideas were incorporated into the Great Compromise, which proposed a bicameral legislature with both proportional and equal representation
The New Jersey Plan and the Virginia Plan: A Debate on State Representation at the Constitutional Convention of 1787
Learn with Algor Education flashcards
Click on each Card to learn more about the topic
00
The ______ Plan, proposed by ______ ______ during the ______ Convention of 1787, was designed to protect the interests of smaller states.
New Jersey
William
Paterson
Constitutional
01
Unlike the ______ Plan which favored proportional representation, the ______ Plan suggested a single-chamber congress where each state would have equal ______.
Virginia
New Jersey
representation
02
The plan introduced by ______ ______ sought to strengthen the federal government's ability to ______ taxes and oversee ______, while keeping states equal in the legislative body.
William
Paterson
levy
commerce
