Andrew Johnson's Reconstruction Policies

Concept Map

Algorino

Edit available

President Andrew Johnson's Reconstruction policies post-Civil War aimed to reintegrate Southern states with minimal societal change. His lenient approach, including the Ten Percent Plan and pardons for Confederates, faced opposition from Radical Republicans, leading to his impeachment and a shift in Reconstruction efforts.

Summary

Outline

President Andrew Johnson's Reconstruction Policies

After the Civil War, President Andrew Johnson was responsible for guiding the nation through the complex process of Reconstruction. His policies aimed to quickly restore the Southern states to the Union with minimal changes to their pre-war social structures. Johnson's plan required that 10% of the 1860 voting population in Confederate states pledge allegiance to the Union and that these states ratify the Thirteenth Amendment, abolishing slavery. However, his lenient approach did not demand equal rights for freedmen and allowed many former Confederates to regain political power, which led to significant opposition and challenges.

19th-century office with wax figure in black tailcoat, wooden desk with books and quill, unframed oil painting of post-Civil War city, and brass-doorknob door.

The Ten Percent Plan and Constitutional Amendments

The cornerstone of Johnson's Reconstruction was the "Ten Percent Plan," which allowed a former Confederate state to rejoin the Union once 10% of its 1860 voters took an oath of allegiance. Critics argued that this plan was too lenient and failed to ensure the political and social transformation of the South. Johnson's plan also required states to revise their constitutions to abolish slavery but did not enforce broader civil rights for African Americans. This lack of specificity and enforcement mechanisms allowed Southern states to implement measures that continued to suppress the rights of freedmen.

The Emergence of Black Codes

Johnson's Reconstruction policies did not provide adequate protections for African Americans, leading to the establishment of Black Codes across the South. These laws restricted the freedom of African Americans, compelling them to enter into labor contracts that resembled the antebellum slave system. The Black Codes also imposed severe penalties for contract breaches and vagrancy, effectively criminalizing unemployment and enabling forced labor. This perpetuated a cycle of exploitation and discrimination against African Americans, undermining the goals of Reconstruction.

Presidential Pardons and the Restoration of Confederate Influence

Johnson's Reconstruction included a generous pardon policy for former Confederates, which allowed many to reclaim their property and political positions. Unlike Lincoln's more selective approach, Johnson's pardons did not exclude high-ranking Confederate officials or those who had mistreated Union prisoners. This policy facilitated the return of Confederate leaders to positions of influence, undermining efforts to reshape Southern society and politics in a more equitable manner.

Congressional Resistance to Johnson's Reconstruction

Johnson's lenient Reconstruction policies faced strong opposition from the Radical Republicans in Congress, who sought to secure citizenship and voting rights for African Americans, along with access to education and healthcare. The Radical Republicans' vision for Reconstruction was more transformative, aiming to fundamentally alter the social and political landscape of the post-war South. Their opposition to Johnson's approach led to a legislative struggle that would redefine the course of Reconstruction.

The Impeachment of President Andrew Johnson

The clash between President Johnson and the Radical Republicans reached a climax when Johnson violated the Tenure of Office Act by attempting to remove Secretary of War Edwin Stanton, a Radical Republican ally. This act precipitated Johnson's impeachment by the House of Representatives in 1868. Although he was not convicted by the Senate and removed from office, the impeachment process weakened his presidency and underscored the intense disagreements over the direction of Reconstruction.

Evaluating Johnson's Reconstruction Efforts

Historically, Andrew Johnson's Reconstruction efforts are considered largely ineffective in achieving the broader goals of rebuilding the nation and protecting the rights of freed slaves. His policies allowed for the swift reestablishment of white-dominated governments in the South and failed to dismantle the social and economic structures that perpetuated racial inequality. The shortcomings of Johnson's approach and his impeachment highlighted the profound challenges of reconciling the nation after civil war and paved the way for the more radical phase of Reconstruction led by Congress.