The Rise of Progressive Reforms in the United States
Concept Map
The Progressive Era marked a period of significant reforms across various states, with Wisconsin leading in primary elections, workers' compensation, and state income tax. Ohio's municipal reforms introduced the city manager system, while Kansas saw a blend of progressivism and populism. Iowa's 'Iowa Idea' brought about railway regulation and women's suffrage. These state-level initiatives collectively shaped national policies and social standards.
Summary
Outline
The Rise of Progressive Reforms in Wisconsin
At the dawn of the 20th century, Wisconsin emerged as a vanguard of progressive reforms, largely due to the efforts of leaders like Robert M. La Follette and Governor Francis E. McGovern. These reforms were groundbreaking and included the nation's first comprehensive statewide primary election system, a pioneering workers' compensation law, and the implementation of a progressive state income tax. The objectives of these reforms were to enhance democratic engagement, provide protections for workers, and create a more equitable tax system. Despite their initial success, the progressive movement in Wisconsin was not immune to internal strife. Conflicts, particularly between La Follette and McGovern, arose over issues such as tax policy, leading to a split that ultimately diminished their collective impact. This division, exacerbated by personal rivalries, allowed the conservative "Stalwarts" to regain political power, culminating in the election of Governor Emanuel Philipp in 1914.The Wisconsin Idea: Bridging Academia and Government
The "Wisconsin Idea" represented a significant progressive reform that aimed to apply the expertise of the University of Wisconsin faculty to state governance and public policy. This collaboration led to the expansion of the university's reach through the UW-Extension system, which extended educational resources to the state's farming communities. Notable contributions from university economists, such as John R. Commons and Harold Groves, included the creation of the first unemployment compensation program in the United States in 1932. Furthermore, Wisconsin scholars were instrumental in developing the Social Security Act of 1935, with Arthur J. Altmeyer being a key figure in its formation. However, the close ties between the university and state government were not without criticism. The Stalwarts argued that this partnership resulted in overregulation and a shift away from undergraduate education towards advanced research. This led to academic freedom disputes, causing a rift within the academic community and prompting the departure of renowned historian Frederick Jackson Turner to Harvard.Progressivism Versus Populism in Kansas: A Comparative Perspective
In Kansas, progressivism and populism were two distinct political movements with separate constituencies and goals. Populism, with deep roots in the agricultural sector, championed radical egalitarianism and the interests of the underprivileged. Progressivism, which emerged from urban business and professional circles, emphasized efficiency, the elimination of waste, and the promotion of social mobility. Despite their differences, both movements shared a common disdain for corruption and monopolistic trusts. As the 20th century progressed, some former Populists began to support progressive reforms, suggesting an ideological convergence between the two movements.Municipal Reform and the Adoption of the City Manager System in Ohio
Ohio was a hotbed for municipal reform, with cities like Toledo, Cleveland, Columbus, and Dayton leading the charge. The middle class, who relied on trolleys for their daily commute, supported reforms targeting the monopolistic practices of private transit companies. In Dayton, the advocacy of John Patterson, CEO of National Cash Register, for a city manager form of government marked a significant shift towards prioritizing administrative efficiency and expertise over political influence in city governance. The catastrophic flood in Dayton in 1913 provided a practical demonstration of Patterson's business acumen, leading to the implementation of his governance model and the subsequent adoption of the city manager system in other municipalities across the United States.The Iowa Idea and Its Progressive Champions
The "Iowa Idea" encapsulated the state's unique brand of progressivism, spearheaded by Governor and later Senator Albert Baird Cummins. Under Cummins' leadership, Iowa enacted several progressive measures, such as the introduction of the direct primary system, regulation of railway fares, and prohibition of corporate campaign contributions. Although Cummins faced challenges in his attempts to reduce protective tariffs at the national level, his state-level reforms were significant. The women's suffrage movement also gained momentum in Iowa, with organizations like the Woman's Christian Temperance Union at the forefront. Despite initial resistance, the movement culminated in the ratification of the 19th Amendment in 1920, granting women the right to vote nationwide.Defining the Progressive Era: Key Ideas and Reforms
The Progressive Era was characterized by a multitude of ideas and reforms aimed at rectifying the excesses of the Gilded Age. This period saw the enactment of antitrust legislation to break up monopolies, the establishment of primary elections to increase democratic participation, and various government reforms to address corruption and inefficiency. The introduction of the city manager system sought to improve municipal governance, while social reforms addressed issues such as family welfare and juvenile delinquency. Efforts to ensure the safety and purity of food, drugs, and water supplies were also undertaken. The social hygiene movement emerged to promote public health and moral standards, and labor reforms were implemented to safeguard workers' rights and improve working conditions. Collectively, these reforms reflected a widespread desire to enhance American society through government intervention and social advocacy.
Show More
Progressive Reforms in Wisconsin
Leaders of the Progressive Movement
Robert M. La Follette and Governor Francis E. McGovern were key leaders in the progressive movement in Wisconsin
Groundbreaking Reforms
Statewide Primary Election System
Wisconsin implemented the nation's first comprehensive statewide primary election system as part of their progressive reforms
Workers' Compensation Law
Wisconsin also passed a pioneering workers' compensation law to protect workers' rights
Progressive State Income Tax
The implementation of a progressive state income tax aimed to create a more equitable tax system in Wisconsin
Objectives of the Reforms
The progressive reforms in Wisconsin aimed to enhance democratic engagement, provide protections for workers, and create a more equitable tax system
The Wisconsin Idea
Collaboration between Academia and Government
The "Wisconsin Idea" aimed to apply the expertise of the University of Wisconsin faculty to state governance and public policy
Expansion of University Reach
UW-Extension System
The UW-Extension system extended educational resources to the state's farming communities in Wisconsin
Contributions from University Economists
University economists, such as John R. Commons and Harold Groves, played a key role in creating the first unemployment compensation program in the United States and developing the Social Security Act of 1935
Criticisms of the Partnership
The close ties between the university and state government in Wisconsin were criticized for resulting in overregulation and a shift away from undergraduate education towards advanced research
Progressivism and Populism in Kansas
Distinct Political Movements
Progressivism and populism were two separate political movements in Kansas with different constituencies and goals
Common Goals
Despite their differences, both movements in Kansas shared a common goal of addressing corruption and monopolistic trusts
Ideological Convergence
As the 20th century progressed, some former Populists in Kansas began to support progressive reforms, suggesting an ideological convergence between the two movements
Municipal Reform in Ohio
Hotbed for Municipal Reform
Ohio was a hotbed for municipal reform, with cities like Toledo, Cleveland, Columbus, and Dayton leading the charge
Support from the Middle Class
The middle class in Ohio supported reforms targeting the monopolistic practices of private transit companies
City Manager System
The advocacy of John Patterson, CEO of National Cash Register, for a city manager form of government marked a significant shift towards prioritizing administrative efficiency and expertise over political influence in city governance
The Rise of Progressive Reforms in the United States
Learn with Algor Education flashcards
Click on each Card to learn more about the topic
00
Wisconsin introduced the first ______, a workers' compensation law, and a ______ during the progressive era.
statewide primary election system
progressive state income tax
01
The progressive movement's decline in Wisconsin led to the election of Governor ______ in ______.
Emanuel Philipp
1914
02
UW-Extension system purpose
Expanded Univ. of Wisconsin's reach, providing educational resources to farming communities.
