;
Feedback
What do you think about us?
Your name
Your email
Message
Thucydides' 'History of the Peloponnesian War' is a foundational text in historical study, detailing the conflict between Athens and Sparta. It delves into the complexities of ancient Greek prose and the challenges it presents in interpretation. The work's abrupt ending and potential internal contradictions have sparked scholarly debates. Thucydides' methodology, his influence on subsequent historians, and the preservation of his texts through manuscripts and papyrus fragments are also discussed.
Show More
Thucydides' use of complex ancient Greek prose poses difficulties in grammar, syntax, and semantics
Analysts" vs. "unitarians
Scholars are divided between those who propose multiple layers of composition and those who argue for a cohesive interpretation of Thucydides' work
Scholars have noted potential contradictions within the text, leading to ongoing debates over its composition
Thucydides seldom mentions his sources, preferring to present a unified and authoritative account of events
Scholars have inferred Thucydides' sources through shifts in the narrative and his detailed descriptions of key historical figures
Thucydides' vivid accounts of the thoughts and motivations of historical figures suggest that he often reconstructed them based on their actions and plausible scenarios
Praise from historians
Historians such as J. B. Bury have praised Thucydides for his contributions to the field of history
Emotional depth
H. D. Kitto highlighted the emotional depth in Thucydides' account of the war's suffering
Potential for bias
Philosopher Karl Popper acknowledged Thucydides as a preeminent historian but also pointed out the potential for bias in his work
Thucydides' work has inspired successors such as Xenophon to continue the historical narrative
Despite criticism of his austere style, Thucydides' work remains a fundamental part of historiography and has been translated and respected by historical figures throughout the ages
Notable manuscripts
Manuscripts such as Codex Parisinus Graecus 255 and Codex Vaticanus Graecus 126 have been crucial for the study and dissemination of Thucydides' work
Preservation through European libraries
Thucydides' work has been preserved and transmitted through manuscripts found in European libraries
Valuable insights
Papyrus fragments, such as Papyrus Oxyrhynchus 16 and 17, have provided valuable insights into the historical reception and transmission of Thucydides' work
Ancient engagement
These fragments reveal the ancient engagement with Thucydides' work, highlighting its lasting importance in the classical canon
00
Thucydides' narrative complexity
Challenging Greek prose with intricate grammar, syntax, semantics; interpretation difficulties.
01
Incomplete ending of Thucydides' history
Narrative ends abruptly, missing final six years of war, suggesting unfinished work.
02
Scholarly focus beyond composition debates
Some scholars prioritize study of Thucydides' methods, insights, rather than compositional layers.
