The Quest to Determine the Chronology of Shakespeare's Plays
Concept Map
The chronology of Shakespeare's plays remains a complex puzzle for scholars, involving the analysis of historical records, stylistic changes, and linguistic evolution. Efforts to establish a sequence, such as E. K. Chambers' influential timeline, face challenges due to scarce and ambiguous evidence. Various editions of Shakespeare's works present differing chronologies, reflecting the ongoing academic discourse and the difficulty in pinpointing exact dates of composition.
Summary
Outline
The Quest to Determine the Chronology of Shakespeare's Plays
Scholars have long sought to establish the sequence in which William Shakespeare wrote his plays, a scholarly endeavor that began in earnest with Edmond Malone in the 18th century. This task involves examining both external and internal evidence. External evidence includes historical records such as contemporary references, performance data, and publication details, while internal evidence looks at stylistic changes, thematic development, and linguistic evolution within the plays themselves. Despite the extensive research, uncertainties remain due to the incomplete nature of the surviving evidence, making a definitive chronology challenging to achieve.Challenges in Establishing Shakespeare's Play Chronology
Dating Shakespeare's plays is complicated by the scarcity and ambiguity of historical records. Performance dates, when available, do not necessarily coincide with a play's inception. For example, "Romeo and Juliet" is known to have been performed during Shakespeare's lifetime, despite the earliest recorded performance being much later. Publication dates are similarly unreliable; the First Folio, which published half of Shakespeare's plays, appeared in 1623, seven years after his death. These dates provide only the latest possible time of composition, leaving the actual dates of creation largely speculative.Divergent Theories on Shakespeare's Chronology
The academic community has not reached a consensus on the chronology of Shakespeare's plays, leading to various theories. E. A. J. Honigmann's "early start" theory posits that Shakespeare's career began with "Titus Andronicus" around 1586, earlier than the commonly accepted date. This theory, while intriguing, has not gained widespread acceptance and is seen by some, such as Gary Taylor and Sidney Thomas, as problematic. The debate illustrates the complexity of piecing together Shakespeare's literary timeline.E. K. Chambers' Influential Chronology of Shakespeare's Plays
E. K. Chambers' chronology, detailed in "The Problem of Chronology" within his 1930 work "William Shakespeare: A Study of Facts and Problems," has been highly influential. Chambers proposed a timeline that commences with "Henry VI, Part 2" and "Henry VI, Part 3" around 1590-1591 and concludes with "Henry VIII" and "The Two Noble Kinsmen" in 1612-1613. His systematic approach to Shakespeare's chronology has provided a foundation for further scholarly investigation and debate.Modern Editions and Their Varied Chronologies
Contemporary editions of Shakespeare's "Complete Works" reflect the ongoing scholarly discourse on the order of his plays. Notable editions include "The Riverside Shakespeare," "The Oxford Shakespeare," "The Norton Shakespeare," "The Arden Shakespeare," "The Pelican Shakespeare," and "The RSC Shakespeare." Each edition presents its own chronology, or in some cases, such as "The Arden Shakespeare," eschews chronological ordering altogether. Editions like "The Oxford Shakespeare" incorporate the most recent scholarship to provide estimated dates. These modern compilations underscore the enduring fascination with and complexity of determining the sequence of Shakespeare's oeuvre.
Show More
External Evidence
Historical Records
Scholars use historical records such as contemporary references, performance data, and publication details to determine the chronology of Shakespeare's plays
Performance Dates
Performance dates, when available, do not necessarily coincide with a play's inception, making it difficult to establish a definitive chronology
Publication Dates
Publication dates, such as the First Folio in 1623, provide only the latest possible time of composition, leaving the actual dates of creation largely speculative
Internal Evidence
Stylistic Changes
Scholars analyze stylistic changes within the plays themselves to determine the order in which they were written
Thematic Development
The evolution of themes within Shakespeare's plays can provide insight into their chronological order
Linguistic Evolution
Changes in language and vocabulary within the plays can also help establish their chronology
Divergent Theories
Early Start Theory
E. A. J. Honigmann's theory suggests that Shakespeare's career began earlier than commonly accepted, but it has not gained widespread acceptance
Chambers' Chronology
E. K. Chambers' influential chronology, proposed in his 1930 work "William Shakespeare: A Study of Facts and Problems," has provided a foundation for further scholarly debate
Modern Editions
Contemporary editions of Shakespeare's works reflect ongoing scholarly discourse and incorporate the most recent research to provide estimated dates for his plays
The Quest to Determine the Chronology of Shakespeare's Plays
Learn with Algor Education flashcards
Click on each card to learn more about the topic
00
To establish the timeline of Shakespeare's works, scholars examine ______ evidence like historical records and ______ evidence such as stylistic changes.
external
internal
01
External evidence for Shakespeare's play chronology includes ______ references, ______ data, and details of ______.
contemporary
performance
publication
02
Internal evidence used to date Shakespeare's plays involves analyzing ______ shifts, ______ progression, and the ______ of the language.
stylistic
thematic
evolution
